12 Comments
Aug 26, 2019Liked by Andrew Donlan

SP- Jake Arrieta (2015)

1B- Derek Lee (2005)

2B- Ben Zobrist (2016)

3B- KB (2016)

SS- Javy (2017)

DH- Jim Thome (2006)

LF- Jermaine Dye (2006)

CF- Carlos Quentin (2008)

RF- Sammy Sosa (2001)

C- Geovany Soto (2008)

RP- Aroldis Chapman (2016)

SP2- Chris Sale (2015)

Expand full comment
Aug 26, 2019Liked by Andrew Donlan

We will not limit comments from your father. Besides, it was me who had to sit with you through your first bet of the College Football Season watching the worse display of fundamental football I have ever seen but ending in a win for you.

Expand full comment
Aug 26, 2019Liked by Andrew Donlan

Kenny Lofton CF (2003)

Derrek Lee 1B(2005)

Frank Thomas DH

Sammy Sosa RF

Kris Bryant (2016)

Javy SS (2017)

Jermaine Dye LF (2006)

Pierzynski C (05-06)

Mark Grudzielanek 2B

SP: Arrietta 2015

RP: Bobby Jenks

Close calls: Buehrle, Sale, Magglio, Konerko, Aramis, Borowski, Castro 2011, Iguchi, Carlos Lee, Moises Alou and I simply didn't want to include Chapman.

Expand full comment

Forgot about Kenny Loften great choice

Expand full comment
author

C-Geovany Soto (2007) ROY

1B-Derrek Lee (2005)

2B: Mark DeRosa (2008)

SS: Javier Baez (2018)

3B: Kris Bryant (2016)

P: Jake Arrieta (2015)

I guess we're doing full line-ups...

OF: Jermaine Dye, Sosa, and Aaron Rowand.

Couldn't leave Rowand out, though him and Joe Crede are retrospectively not even close to as good as I thought they were.

Expand full comment

SP - Kerry Wood

C - AJ Pierzynski

1B - Frank Thomas

2B - Mark DeRosa

3B - Crede

SS - Javy

Expand full comment

SP - Jon Lester 2016

C - aj pierzynski 2006

1b - Derek leek 2005

2b - tadahito iguchi 2005

SS - javy Baez 2018

3b - aramis Ramirez 2004

Expand full comment

Going full lineup here:

SP - Chris Sale (2014)

C - AJ Pierzynski (2006)

1B - Frank Thomas (2000)

2B - Yoan Moncada (2019)

3B - Kris Bryant (MVP season)

SS - Javy Baez (2018)

LF - Sammy Sosa (2001)

RF - Jermaine Dye (2005 WS MVP)

CF - Luis Robert (2020)

DH - Jim Thome (2006)

Expand full comment

I forgot about Thome- I blame Adam Dunn for coming in and being a much worse version of him and clouding my judgement

Expand full comment

Moncada????

Expand full comment

Based off of this years stats... absolutely. Have you watched him play this year? .300/.356/.545 is very good

Expand full comment

Yes his OPS for a 24 year old is absurd. If he walks more that’s a 1.000OPS

Expand full comment